Church abuse compensation funds

Available Compensation Funds for Catholic Church Sex Abuse Survivors

Catholic dioceses have established clergy abuse compensation funds to provide financial restitution to survivors of sexual abuse. These funds aim to cover expenses related to the abuse.

A Law Firm That Helps Survivors of Clergy & Church Sexual Abuse

Catholic dioceses have established clergy abuse compensation funds to provide financial restitution to survivors of sexual abuse. These funds aim to cover expenses related to the abuse, such as medical and mental health treatment, lost wages, and other associated costs. By offering these funds, the Church seeks to acknowledge the harm caused and assist survivors in their healing process.

Archdioceses, dioceses, and even state governments use a variety of names for their clergy abuse compensation programs. These programs often include terms like “independent,” “reconciliation,” or “reparations” to emphasize fairness and accountability. For instance, the Archdiocese of Los Angeles established the “Independent Compensation Program (ICP)” to provide financial restitution to individuals sexually abused by clergy under its oversight. A lawyer can help survivors navigate these compensation programs by gathering evidence, ensuring deadlines are met, and maximizing the amount recovered. They also provide crucial support in evaluating whether a fund settlement or civil lawsuit is the better option based on the survivor’s specific circumstances.

How To File A Claim With A Catholic Church Compensation Program

Clergy sexual abuse occurs when a priest, minister, rabbi, or other spiritual leader uses their Compensation funds have specific deadlines for submitting claims, so it’s important to act promptly. Speaking with an attorney beforehand can help you understand the process, gather necessary documentation, and avoid common mistakes.

If you decide to move forward with a claim, you’ll likely interact with a claims coordinator or administrator who oversees the intake and review process. These individuals often work with a committee that evaluates each claim’s credibility and determines the appropriate compensation amount.

About Compensation Funds Created By The Roman Catholic Church

Catholic Church compensation programs are designed to provide financial restitution to individuals harmed by clergy abuse. These programs became more common after a 2002 Boston Globe investigation exposed a widespread cover-up of child sexual abuse within Catholic dioceses. In the years since, compensation funds have become a standard response from dioceses facing allegations of clergy abuse.

By offering financial settlements through these programs, dioceses may avoid lengthy civil court proceedings. In most cases, survivors who accept a payout are required to waive their right to pursue further legal action against the Church. Experts note that compensation funds can significantly reduce the financial and reputational cost to the Church.

Diocese / Archdiocese Status Estimated Payouts Eligibility
Archdiocese of New York – Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program (IRCP) Closed (program ran Oct 2016 – Nov 1, 2017 deadline) $40 million paid to 189 survivors (as of Nov 2017) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Archdiocese of NY clergy (no time limit on when abuse occurred)
Diocese of Brooklyn – Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program (IRCP) Closed (Phase I deadline Sept 30, 2017; Phase II deadline March 31, 2018) >$90 million paid to ~500 survivors (as of Aug 2019) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Brooklyn diocesan priests or deacons (no time limit; program was voluntary)
Diocese of Rockville Centre – Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program (IRCP) Closed (program concluded; final deadline Sept 25, 2020) >$50 million paid to 277 survivors (offers accepted as of Sept 2019) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Diocese of RVC clergy (no time limit on abuse; voluntary fund)
Diocese of Syracuse – Independent Reconciliation Compensation Program (IRCP) Closed (program ran Feb 2018 – ~Apr 2019) ~$10.9 million paid to 79 survivors (88 claims filed, 79 resolved by Apr 2019) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Syracuse diocesan clergy (program invited known victims; voluntary)
Diocese of Buffalo – Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program (IRCP) Closed (launched Mar 2018; suspended in 2020 due to Chapter 11) ~$17.5 million paid to 106 survivors (127 awards offered; avg ~$164k each) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Buffalo diocesan clergy (had to report abuse by Mar 1, 2018 to be eligible)
Diocese of Ogdensburg – Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program (IRCP) Closed (program concluded in 2018) ~$5.5 million paid to ~37 survivors (38 claims resolved via IRCP) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Ogdensburg diocesan clergy (voluntary program; outreach to prior claimants)
NJ Catholic Dioceses – Independent Victim Compensation Program (IVCP) Closed (statewide fund open Jun 2019 – Jan 31, 2020 deadline) >95 claims deemed eligible (out of ~560 filed); at least $11 million paid by Jan 2020 (e.g. Camden paid $8.1M to 71 victims) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in NJ dioceses (no limitation on time of abuse; open to all victims statewide)
Diocese of Allentown (PA) – Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program (IRCP) Closed (open Apr 23 – Sept 30, 2019 for applications) $16.02 million paid to 97 survivors (103 claims eligible; a few offers rejected) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Allentown diocesan priests (and certain religious-order priests in Diocese)
Diocese of Erie (PA) – Independent Survivors’ Reparation Program Closed (Feb 15 – Aug 15, 2019) $16.6 million total paid to survivors (incl. $5.9M to 50 claimants via fund by Dec 2019) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Erie diocesan clergy (no time limit on abuse; independent admin)
Diocese of Greensburg (PA) – Independent Reconciliation Compensation Program Closed (Feb – May 2019 claims window) ~$5.9 million paid to 72 survivors (72 offers accepted) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Greensburg diocesan clergy (no time bar on claims; independent fund)
Diocese of Harrisburg (PA) – Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program Closed (Feb – May 2019) $12.1 million paid to 106 survivors (112 claims eligible; most accepted) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Harrisburg diocesan clergy (all epochs eligible; independent admin)
Diocese of Scranton (PA) – Independent Survivors Compensation Program (ISCP) Closed (Jan 2019 launch; new claims by July 31, 2019; final deadline Sept 30, 2019) $24.46 million paid to 213 survivors (249 claims deemed eligible; majority paid) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Diocese of Scranton clergy, including priests, religious order clergy, or lay employees affiliated with the diocese
Diocese of Pittsburgh (PA) – Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program (IRCP) Closed (Jan 2019 launch; extended until Oct 2020 closure) >$19 million paid to 224 survivors (297 claims eligible; 224 offers accepted) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Pittsburgh diocesan priests or deacons (no time limit; independent admin by Feinberg/Biros)
Archdiocese of Philadelphia – Independent Reconciliation and Reparations Program (IRRP) Closed (launched Nov 2018; claims deadline Sept 30, 2019) $78.5 million paid (of $81 million awarded) to 438 survivors Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Archdiocese of Phila. clergy (no time limit; must report abuse to law enforcement)
California (6 Dioceses) – Independent Compensation Program (ICP) Closed (opened Sept 16, 2019; closed Feb 29, 2020) $23.97 million paid to 197 survivors (197 claims accepted out of ~580 filed) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by diocesan priests of the 6 participating CA dioceses (no SOL time-bar; open to all, including undocumented)
Colorado (3 Dioceses) – Independent Reconciliation and Reparations Program (IRRP) Closed (opened Oct 7, 2019; claims deadline Jan 31, 2020) $6.68 million paid to 73 survivors (81 claims eligible; 73 paid as of Oct 2020) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by diocesan priests (or bishops) of the three CO dioceses (no SOL limit; independent fund run with CO Attorney General’s support)
Diocese of Richmond (VA) – Independent Reconciliation Program (IRP) Closed (launched Feb 17, 2020; closed Oct 15, 2020) $6.3 million paid to 51 survivors (51 offers accepted; 68 claims initiated) Survivors of childhood sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in Diocese of Richmond (no time limit on abuse; independent claims administrator)

Unlike lawsuits, which can lead to the public release of internal Church documents detailing abuse and cover-ups, compensation programs typically allow dioceses to resolve claims privately—keeping potentially damaging information out of the public eye. However, lawsuits can lead to more compensation and force organizations to take more corrective actions to prevent future occurrences of sexual abuse and misconduct.

Kayla's Survivors symbol logo

Catholic Church Compensation Program VS Lawsuit

When seeking justice for clergy sexual abuse, survivors typically have two primary avenues: pursuing a Church-run compensation fund or initiating a civil lawsuit. Each option has distinct processes, benefits, and limitations.

Civil Lawsuits

Process: Survivors file a legal complaint against the abuser and potentially the institution that enabled the abuse. This process involves legal discovery, potential court proceedings, and, in some cases, a trial.

Pros:

  • Potential for Higher Compensation: Civil lawsuits can result in substantial financial awards, including punitive damages, especially if the institution is found negligent.
  • Public Accountability: Lawsuits can lead to the disclosure of internal documents and testimonies, shedding light on systemic issues and institutional cover-ups.
  • Legal Precedent: Successful cases can set precedents that influence future litigation and institutional reforms.

Cons:

  • Longer Duration: The legal process can be lengthy, often taking months or years to reach a resolution.
  • Emotional Toll: Recounting traumatic experiences in a legal setting can be emotionally challenging for survivors.
  • Public Exposure: Court proceedings are typically public, which might compromise the survivor’s privacy.

Church Compensation Funds

Process: These are programs established by dioceses or archdioceses to provide financial restitution to survivors without litigation. Claims are reviewed by appointed administrators or committees.

Pros:

  • Expedited Resolution: Claims are often processed within a few months, providing quicker access to compensation.
  • Privacy: The process is confidential, helping protect the survivor’s identity and personal details.
  • Less Adversarial: The non-litigious nature can be less stressful for survivors seeking closure.

Cons:

Limited Transparency: These programs might not lead to the public disclosure of information about the abuse or institutional accountability.

Waiver of Legal Rights: Accepting compensation usually requires the survivor to forgo the right to pursue further legal action against the Church.

Potentially Lower Compensation: Payouts from compensation funds may be less than what could be awarded through a lawsuit.

Choosing between a civil lawsuit and a Church compensation fund is a deeply personal decision that depends on various factors, including the survivor’s desired outcome, emotional readiness, and the specifics of their case. Consulting with our experienced attorneys can provide invaluable guidance. We can help assess the merits of your case, explain the potential outcomes of each option, and support you throughout the chosen process. Remember, seeking justice is your right, and support is available to help you navigate this journey. Call (800) 509-9747 or request a free case evaluation online to get started. 

The sexual abuse attorneys at Kayla’s Survivors have helped recover over $1 billion in compensation as a result of settlements and verdicts, including claims made against churches and clergy members.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What types of abuse were eligible for Catholic Church compensation funds?

Most compensation programs accepted claims involving childhood sexual abuse by clergy, including priests, deacons, or diocesan employees. Some funds also accepted claims against religious order members and lay personnel affiliated with the diocese.

Do survivors need to provide documentation to file a claim?

Yes. Survivors were typically asked to provide supporting documents such as personal statements, therapy records, witness accounts, or any prior complaints or reports. While documentation helped, many programs accepted credible claims even without formal evidence.

Were there time limits on when the abuse occurred?

No. Most diocesan compensation funds allowed claims regardless of when the abuse occurred, including incidents from decades ago. This was especially important for survivors who were barred by civil statutes of limitations.

Could a survivor file if the abuser was deceased?

Yes. Many compensation programs allowed survivors to file claims even if the accused clergy member was deceased or no longer part of the diocese. Credibility of the claim, not the abuser’s status, was the key consideration.

Could a survivor file if the abuse was never previously reported?

Yes. Programs generally allowed first-time reports and did not require prior complaints or lawsuits. However, all claims were reviewed by an independent panel for credibility.

Case Types